Closing a pension scheme to accrual – a more relaxed approach?

As more DB pension schemes have closed in recent years, one of the most problematic issues for many employers is where scheme rules are deemed to prevent them from fully breaking the link with members’ final salaries. The Courage case from 1987 has long been authority that, in some cases, a scheme’s rules can mean that employees’ future salaries are still taken into account in benefit calculations, even after the scheme is closed.

The High Court recently ruled that a termination notice given by a group of employers was effective to stop future accrual in the scheme and to break the final salary link. The decision turned on the scope of the amendment power and gives some hope to those who continue to argue that the more restrictive interpretation applied in Courage should be overruled.

What was the case about?

The case concerned the Wedgwood Group Pension Plan (the Plan).

The rules of the Plan were re-written in 2001 (the 2001 Rules), replacing the previous rules which dated from 1995 (the 1995 Rules). The 2001 Rule at the centre of this case (the Termination Power) gave a participating employer the power to “stop contributing in respect of all or some of its employees by giving written notice to the Trustees”. This widened the circumstances whereby a participating employer could cease to participate in the Plan as the 1995 Rules had required it to be “impracticable or inexpedient for such Company to continue to participate in the Plan”.

The closure of the Plan was carried out in two stages. The first stage happened in 2001 when the 1995 Rules were amended to give the employer the power to terminate accrual through notice to the trustee. The second stage happened in 2006 when the participating employers gave such notice to the trustee.

The trustee issued proceedings in the High Court. The purpose was to establish whether the employers’ notice was effective to close the Plan to accrual and to break the final salary link.

Why was the rule being challenged?

The amendment power in the 1995 Rules provided that “no alteration modification or addition shall be made which…shall prejudice or adversely affect any pension or annuity then payable or the rights of any Member”.

The trustee argued that the fetter in this power only protected members’ accrued rights. The representative beneficiary argued that future rights were protected, the Termination Power was not validly introduced and the notice to terminate was therefore ineffective.

Click to view all articles for the EPIC:
Or click to view the full company profile:
    Facebook
    Twitter
    LinkedIn
    Gateley Holdings Plc

    More articles like this

    Hardman & Co

    Gateley Plc Excellent full-year results

    Gateley reported another strong set of results, again beating market expectations, underlining its consistency and predictable performance. A broad-based, legal and professional services group, Gateley is a leader in serving the UK mid-market. It continues to

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    Gateley Holdings plc Revenue up 20.1% to £46.4m

    Michael Ward, CEO of Gateley, said: “I am delighted with the performance of the business in the first half of the financial year. Our proven strong and resilient business model and our focused diversification strategy has

    Hardman & Co

    Gateley Plc Strong trading and industry opportunity

    Gateley Plc (LON:GTLY) trading statement in respect of 1H 2019 was sparkling, with 20% revenue growth in 1H and a highly confident outlook for 2H. We expect to revise our forecasts up by £2m at the

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    Gateley Holdings strong financial performance continues

    Commenting, Michael Ward, Chief Executive Officer of Gateley, said: “Our strong financial performance continues to enable the Board to invest in the future of the Group. It’s been a busy six months, including the acquisitions of

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    Gateley (Holdings) Plc Acquisition of Kiddy & Partners

    Commenting on the acquisition, Michael Ward, Chief Executive Officer of Gateley said: “This acquisition significantly broadens and strengthens our Employment and People Services offering. There will be clear opportunities for us to collaborate and deliver integrated

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    Gateley Holdings Plc Trading Update

    Gateley Holdings Plc (LON:GTLY), the national commercial law and complementary professional services group, has today announced an update on trading ahead of its audited results for the financial year ended 30 April 2018.   Trading in

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    NDAs: out of the shadows and into the spotlight

    Confidentiality or non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) are regularly used in business to keep matters such as financial information and sensitive trading data out of the public domain. In most M&A transactions the parties will enter into an

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    If the (compensation) cap doesn’t fit…

    Following a referral by the Court of Appeal to the European Court of Justice (ECJ), the Advocate General (the AG) has given her opinion on the application of Article 8 of the EU’s Insolvency Directive (the Directive) in

    Gateley Holdings Plc

    GATELEY APPOINTS NEW LEEDS OFFICE HEAD

    Listed law firm Gateley has appointed a new Leeds head, replacing the man who founded the office in 2012. Commercial dispute resolution (CDR) partner Andrew Johnson takes over from restructuring partner William Ballmann, who is reducing